阻客貨車搶的士生意

有 的 士 司 機 認 為 ， 我 昨 天 的 建 議 ， 或 許 可 解 決 八 折 黨 的 問 題 ， 但 解 決 不 了 客 貨 車 搶 生 意 的 問 題 。 在 他 看 來 ， 八 折 黨 起 碼 也 是 行 家 ， 一 樣 要 交 的 士 牌 費 ， 大 家 成 本 一 樣 ， 即 使 他 們 減 價 競 爭 ， 也 可 以 算 是 場 公 平 競 爭 ； 但 客 貨 車 的 牌 費 低 很 多 ， 經 營 成 本 較 低 ， 當 然 更 有 條 件 與 的 士 作 減 價 戰 。 政 府 收 了 的 士 的 牌 費 ， 有 責 任 阻 止 客 貨 車 正 面 與 的 士 搶 生 意 。 
 
要 解 決 這 個 問 題 的 確 不 容 易 ， 因 為 客 貨 車 的 存 在 ， 本 身 就 是 為 了 載 客 載 貨 。 原 先 的 條 例 沒 有 對 客 與 貨 的 定 義 作 清 楚 的 界 定 ， 存 在 很 多 灰 色 地 帶 ， 去 機 場 的 人 ， 可 以 把 行 李 視 作 貨 物 ， 為 了 審 慎 ， 所 以 要 上 車 跟 貨 一 起 去 機 場 ， 在 現 有 的 法 例 下 ， 警 方 也 拿 他 們 沒 辦 法 。 
 
我 在 電 台 的 烽 煙 節 目 裡 ， 就 聽 過 有 客 貨 車 的 車 主 投 訴 ， 說 他 是 送 家 人 去 旅 行 ， 為 何 不 許 他 選 擇 自 己 方 便 的 停 車 場 ， 非 要 他 們 停 在 較 遠 的 3號 停 車 場 ？ 在 場 負 責 回 答 聽 眾 問 題 的 官 員 ， 自 知 理 據 不 足 ， 只 好 顧 左 右 而 言 他 。 
 
其 實 ， 這 種 限 制 使 用 停 車 場 的 做 法 ， 最 多 製 造 客 貨 車 接 客 離 開 機 場 的 麻 煩 ， 但 送 客 去 機 場 ， 根 本 不 用 去 停 車 場 ， 起 不 了 太 大 的 作 用 。 要 解 決 這 個 問 題 ， 關 鍵 要 重 新 立 法 ， 為 客 貨 車 可 載 的 貨 與 客 作 清 楚 的 定 義 。 
 
譬 如 ： 法 律 可 規 定 隨 身 使 用 的 行 李 不 算 可 託 運 的 貨 品 ， 這 已 足 以 使 大 部 分 去 機 場 的 客 貨 車 沒 法 繼 續 經 營 下 去 。 因 為 要 判 斷 甚 麼 是 隨 身 行 李 並 不 難 ， 普 通 警 員 也 應 具 備 這 種 常 識 。 一 般 的 貨 品 ， 如 需 要 運 輸 ， 用 紙 皮 箱 包 裝 已 可 以 ， 沒 有 人 會 喜 歡 用 行 李 箱 來 運 貨 的 。 因 此 ， 不 用 打 開 行 李 箱 ， 犯 例 者 就 會 自 知 理 虧 ， 不 會 死 撐 下 去 。 
 
此 外 ， 為 了 防 止 有 人 利 用 接 送 親 友 ， 一 併 運 送 行 李 ， 可 把 客 人 的 定 義 增 闊 為 原 先 與 司 機 或 車 主 不 認 識 的 人 。 這 樣 就 不 用 一 定 要 搜 集 到 錢 銀 轇 轕 的 證 據 ， 也 可 以 進 行 起 訴 ， 警 員 只 要 問 一 些 簡 單 的 問 題 ， 就 可 以 知 道 他 們 是 否 真 正 認 識 司 機 或 車 主 。 普 通 客 人 也 不 會 因 貪 平 而 以 身 試 法 。 為 了 執 行 這 樣 的 新 例 ， 警 方 毋 須 截 查 所 有 出 入 機 場 的 客 貨 車 ， 這 樣 會 過 度 擾 民 。 警 方 只 需 有 針 對 性 地 截 查 那 些 經 常 出 入 機 場 的 客 貨 車 ， 相 信 已 有 相 當 高 的 命 中 率 ， 可 以 起 殺 一 儆 百 的 作 用 。 
 
如 果 警 方 自 己 沒 有 人 手 ， 可 發 動 的 士 司 機 舉 報 ， 的 士 司 機 為 了 自 己 的 生 計 ， 一 定 不 會 怕 做 醜 人 。 況 且 ， 警 方 只 需 利 用 的 士 司 機 提 供 的 線 索 ， 毋 須 的 士 司 機 當 證 人 ， 肯 舉 報 的 人 一 定 會 多 。 警 方 只 需 向 最 多 人 舉 報 的 客 貨 車 下 手 ， 應 該 很 快 便 可 以 產 生 阻 嚇 力 。 
 
(轉 載 自 2007年 7月 25日 am730 C觀 點 )